Every year, Girl Scout cookies bring a wave of nostalgia and excitement, but choosing the best ones can be tricky with so many options. Thin Mints remain a perennial favorite thanks to their crisp chocolate coating and refreshing mint flavor, while Do-si-dos are perfect for peanut butter lovers seeking a hearty snack. Meanwhile, Lemon-Ups offer a zesty, seasonal twist for those craving citrus. Each cookie has its unique appeal, but tradeoffs in flavor variety, dietary considerations, or seasonal availability shape the decision for different buyers.
Here, I’ve curated the best Girl Scout cookies for 2026, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses to help you pick the perfect match for your tastes and needs.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Thin Mints are ideal for mint and chocolate lovers seeking a crunchy, refreshing treat.
- Lemon-Ups provide a seasonal citrus burst, best for those craving a tangy snack.
- Coconut Fudge and Caramel cookies mimic Samoa flavors but offer limited variety.
- Do-si-dos are perfect for peanut butter fans but lack flavor diversity.
- Availability can be seasonal, especially for Lemon-Ups, influencing when to buy.
| Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cookies 7oz – Pack of 2 |  | Best for Coconut & Caramel Fans | Size: 2 x 7oz packs | Flavor profile: Coconut fudge and caramel | Contains: Added sugars | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cookies 7oz. – Just Like Samoas |  | Closest to Original Samoas | Size: 7oz | Flavor profile: Coconut, caramel, chocolate | Contains: Added sugars | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Girl Scout Thin Mints Cookies (32 per box) |  | Best for Mint Chocolate Fans | Size: 32 cookies | Flavor profile: Mint and chocolate | Contains: Chocolate, sugar | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Do-si-dos Cookies (2 Boxes) |  | Best for Peanut Butter Lovers | Size: 2 boxes | Flavor profile: Peanut butter | Contains: Added sugars | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Girl Scout Cookies Lemon-Ups – 4 Boxes |  | Best Seasonal Citrus Treat | Size: 4 boxes | Flavor profile: Lemon | Contains: Added sugars | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Girl Scout cookie | Size | Flavor profile | Contains | Packaging |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cook | 2 x 7oz packs | Coconut fudge and caramel | Added sugars | Resealable packs |
| Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cook | 7oz | Coconut, caramel, chocolate | Added sugars | Sealed pouch |
| Girl Scout Thin Mints Cookies | 32 cookies | Mint and chocolate | Chocolate, sugar | Box of 32 |
| Do-si-dos Cookies | 2 boxes | Peanut butter | Added sugars | 2 boxes |
| Girl Scout Cookies Lemon-Ups | 4 boxes | Lemon | Added sugars | 4 boxes |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cookies 7oz – Pack of 2
This option stands out for its rich coconut fudge and caramel flavor, closely resembling the iconic Samoa cookies but at a more accessible price point. The inclusion of two 7oz packs makes it convenient for sharing or snacking over multiple occasions. Compared with the Samoa original, these cookies lack some of the nuanced chocolate and coconut balance; they also contain added sugars, which might concern health-conscious buyers. While they lack variety, their satisfying flavor makes them a solid pick for coconut lovers seeking a convenient, budget-friendly snack.
Pros:- Rich coconut and caramel flavor
- Great for snacking or sharing
- Includes two packs for convenience
Cons:- Limited flavor variety
- Contains added sugars
- No detailed nutritional info provided
Best for: Coconut and caramel flavor enthusiasts looking for a tasty, shareable snack
Not ideal for: Those seeking a broader variety or low-sugar options
- Size:2 x 7oz packs
- Flavor profile:Coconut fudge and caramel
- Contains:Added sugars
- Packaging:Resealable packs
- Shelf life:6 months
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“A satisfying coconut and caramel treat that offers good value but limited variety.”
Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cookies 7oz. – Just Like Samoas
This product makes sense for those craving the authentic Samoa experience, with a sweet blend of coconut, caramel, and chocolate flavors. The 7oz package is well-sized for sharing or individual enjoyment. However, compared with other options, it lacks detailed specifications and doesn’t have customer reviews to verify quality, which may lead to hesitation. If authenticity matters most to you, this cookie offers a close approximation but might fall short on consistency and nutritional transparency.
Pros:- Delicious coconut and caramel flavor
- Resembles popular Samoas cookies
- Good size for sharing or individual enjoyment
Cons:- No detailed specifications
- Lack of reviews or ratings
- Potential inconsistency in flavor
Best for: Fans of Samoa looking for a similar flavor experience
Not ideal for: Buyers who prioritize detailed product info or reviews
- Size:7oz
- Flavor profile:Coconut, caramel, chocolate
- Contains:Added sugars
- Packaging:Sealed pouch
- Shelf life:6 months
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“A decent alternative for Samoa fans, but limited transparency makes it a cautious choice.”
Girl Scout Thin Mints Cookies (32 per box)
This classic choice features crispy chocolate wafers coated in a refreshing mint chocolaty shell. The box of 32 makes it ideal for regular snacking or sharing at gatherings. Its crunchy texture and cool mint flavor make it a perennial favorite, but the ingredient list isn’t fully detailed, and some may find the chocolate-mint combination too intense or unsuitable for dietary restrictions. Compared to other cookies, Thin Mints are less versatile but excel in delivering that crisp, minty crunch everyone loves.
Pros:- Crispy texture with a rich mint chocolate flavor
- Convenient box of 32 servings
- Great for snacking or sharing
Cons:- Contains chocolate and mint, which may not suit all diets
- Limited info on ingredients
- Potentially high in sugars
Best for: Mint chocolate lovers seeking a refreshing, crunchy treat
Not ideal for: Those avoiding chocolate or mint flavors
- Size:32 cookies
- Flavor profile:Mint and chocolate
- Contains:Chocolate, sugar
- Packaging:Box of 32
- Shelf life:12 months
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“A quintessential mint cookie that delivers crispness and refreshment, perfect for mint fans.”
Do-si-dos Cookies (2 Boxes)
These classic peanut butter-filled cookies are satisfying for anyone who loves rich, nutty flavors. The two boxes provide ample servings for sharing or enjoying over time. While they hit the spot for peanut butter fans, their limited flavor profile might leave those seeking variety wanting more. The presence of added sugars also makes them less ideal for health-conscious buyers. Compared to more diverse options, Do-si-dos are straightforward but lack novelty.
Pros:- Delicious peanut butter flavor
- Great for snacking or sharing
- Two boxes offer good value
Cons:- Limited flavor variety
- Contains added sugars
- No detailed nutritional info
Best for: Peanut butter aficionados seeking a hearty, satisfying snack
Not ideal for: Those looking for a variety of flavors or low-sugar options
- Size:2 boxes
- Flavor profile:Peanut butter
- Contains:Added sugars
- Packaging:2 boxes
- Shelf life:8 months
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“A reliable peanut butter treat, ideal for fans but limited in diversity.”
Girl Scout Cookies Lemon-Ups – 4 Boxes
These Lemon-Ups burst with a bright lemon flavor, making them a perfect seasonal treat for citrus lovers. The four-box pack is especially convenient for those who want to stock up during the limited season. However, their availability is restricted to specific times of the year, and they contain added sugars like most cookies. If you enjoy tangy, refreshing flavors and don’t mind the seasonal aspect, Lemon-Ups stand out as a lively, citrusy option, though their limited window may mean you miss out if you don’t plan ahead.
Pros:- Fresh lemon flavor
- Convenient pack of 4 boxes
- Popular seasonal treat
Cons:- Only available seasonally
- Contains added sugars
- Limited availability
Best for: Lemon and citrus fans seeking a seasonal snack
Not ideal for: Those wanting year-round availability or low-sugar options
- Size:4 boxes
- Flavor profile:Lemon
- Contains:Added sugars
- Packaging:4 boxes
- Shelf life:6 months
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“A lively, lemony cookie best enjoyed during its seasonal window, perfect for citrus enthusiasts.”
How We Picked
To determine the best Girl Scout cookies, I evaluated each product based on flavor authenticity, ingredient transparency, variety, packaging convenience, and overall value. I compared similar options, like coconut fudge cookies that resemble Samoa, to see which more closely match the original taste and texture. I also considered the suitability for different dietary preferences and the practicality of each package size. This approach ensures I highlight options that appeal to a broad range of cookie enthusiasts, from casual snackers to dedicated fans.
| Girl Scout cookie | Flavor profile | Contains |
|---|---|---|
| Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cook | Coconut fudge and caramel | Added sugars |
| Coconut Fudge and Caramel Cook | Coconut, caramel, chocolate | Added sugars |
| Girl Scout Thin Mints Cookies | Mint and chocolate | Chocolate, sugar |
| Do-si-dos Cookies | Peanut butter | Added sugars |
| Girl Scout Cookies Lemon-Ups | Lemon | Added sugars |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Girl Scout Cookies
Selecting the best Girl Scout cookies depends on your flavor preferences, dietary needs, and whether you prioritize classic favorites or seasonal varieties. Each cookie offers a different experience, and understanding their unique qualities can help you make a satisfying choice.
Flavor Preferences
If you love mint, Thin Mints are the clear winner for their refreshing crunch. For rich, coconutty sweetness, Samoa-inspired options are ideal, but keep in mind their added sugars and limited variety. Those seeking peanut butter should consider Do-si-dos for their hearty filling, while citrus lovers will enjoy Lemon-Ups during their seasonal run.
Dietary Considerations
Many of these cookies contain added sugars and some include chocolate or mint, which might not suit all dietary restrictions. If you’re looking for lower-sugar options or have allergies, check ingredient lists carefully. For example, Thin Mints tend to have a high sugar content, while some options like Samoa mimic traditional recipes but lack detailed nutritional info.
Seasonal Availability
Seasonal cookies like Lemon-Ups are only available during specific times of the year, so plan your purchase accordingly. Regular favorites like Thin Mints or Do-si-dos are typically available year-round, offering greater flexibility. Consider your timing and whether you want to stock up for future enjoyment.
Packaging & Value
Large boxes of Thin Mints and Do-si-dos offer good value for frequent snacking, while multi-pack options for coconut fudge cookies provide convenience. Seasonal packs might be smaller or limited, so if you’re a big fan, buying in bulk during peak season can be advantageous. Always compare package sizes and price per serving to find the best deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Girl Scout cookies gluten-free?
Most traditional Girl Scout cookies, including Thin Mints and Do-si-dos, contain gluten. However, some varieties have been introduced as gluten-free, but always check the packaging or official sources for the latest information, as recipes and availability can change.
How long do Girl Scout cookies stay fresh?
Typically, Girl Scout cookies can stay fresh for about 6 to 12 months if stored in a cool, dry place. It’s best to consume them within the first few months for optimal taste, especially for cookies with perishable ingredients like coconut or chocolate coatings.
Are Girl Scout cookies suitable for vegans?
Most traditional Girl Scout cookies contain dairy, eggs, or honey, making them unsuitable for vegans. Some varieties, like Thin Mints, are often considered vegan, but always verify ingredients or check for specific vegan labeling to be certain.
Can I buy Girl Scout cookies online?
While Girl Scout cookies are primarily sold through local troop sales, some regions offer online ordering or shipping options. Check with your local Girl Scout council or official website to find out if online purchasing is available in your area.
Are Girl Scout cookies healthy?
These cookies are treats and generally contain added sugars and fats, so they are not considered health foods. For healthier options, look for smaller serving sizes or cookies with fewer added ingredients, but moderation remains key.
Conclusion
If you’re a die-hard fan of mint chocolate, Thin Mints will always be the top pick. For those who prefer hearty, peanut butter-filled snacks, Do-si-dos are the way to go. Citrus lovers should consider stocking up on Lemon-Ups during their seasonal availability. If you want authentic Samoa flavors, the coconut fudge options are worth trying, though they come with limited variety. Consider your flavor preferences, dietary needs, and whether you want year-round or seasonal options when making your choice.
